Sikhs and vegetarianism
The general consensus is that practicing Sikhs shouldn’t be consuming meat, eggs or fish as it is against the Sikh code of conduct and beliefs. One of the beauties of Sikhi is the amazing concept of langar. People of all cultures, castes, faiths sit on the floor and consume a vegetarian meal as one. A true manifestation of equality.
No discrimination, no meat for the privileged – everybody shares the same adequate, death free food.
Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji mentions numerous times about the affects of meat, alcohol and tobacco consumption on not only health but spiritual progression. Killing animals seems to be unjust, unrighteous and unneeded as per Sikh teachings.
“You kill living beings, and call it a righteous action. Tell me, brother, what would you call an unrighteous action? You call yourself the excellent sage; then whom would you call a butcher? (Guru Granth Sahib Ji, 1103).
Bhagat Kabeer also goes on to say, “the dinner of beans and rice is excellent when flavored with salt. Who would cut throats to have meat with his bread?” (Guru Granth Sahib Ji, 1374).
For the people who will bring up specific instances of history where Gurus may have killed animals or ate meat. It’s important to remember the Gurus ideas were largely that meat isn’t needed, it’s for pleasure and that it affects spirituality negatively. Situations of necessity and survival are different such as being on a battlefield where the enemies have stopped your food supplies and you need to survive for the sake of protecting human rights.
Compassion in Sikhi
“The merit of pilgrimages to the sixty-eight holy places, and that of other virtues besides, do not equal having compassion for other living beings.” (Sri Guru Granth Sahib, pg 136)
“Do not cause pain to any creature, Go back to your Home with honour.” (Sri Guru Granth Sahib, pg 322)
“Keep your heart content and cherish compassion for all beings; this way alone can your holy vow be fulfilled” (Sri Guru Granth Sahib, pg 299)
From the concepts of langar, sewa to sharing wealth and helping the defenseless, many of Sikhi teaching are born out of compassion. Not only is this compassion for fellow human beings but all living beings. Daya (translated to compassion or mercy) should be at the forefront of a Sikhs mindset. It is a value held very high in the teachings alongside truth, contentment, love and humility. The importance of compassion is further highlighted in the Japji Sahib where it says Dharma (religion) is the son of compassion, meaning without compassion there is no religion. Wherever injustice and suffering take place, it touches most hearts, that’s our empathetic nature as humans but it is a Sikh’s duty to move forward and act.
Does this mean Sikhs should embrace veganism? Bear with me.
What is Veganism?
According to the Vegan Society (where Veganism began in 1944), Veganism is a way of living which seeks to exclude, as far as is possible and practicable, all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose. Followers of veganism are known as Vegans and they don’t eat or use any animal products (this includes consumption of meat, dairy, eggs, and use of furs, silks and leather etc.).
It was suggested early on that people ought to be vegetarians as a matter of ethics and not only health. Today we know the human body isn’t fit for meat consumption and by nature we are herbivores. The proof is in our long colons, blunt teeth, grinding chewing motion and the obvious fact that we aren’t fast like predators and certainly don’t bite into meat like actual omnivores, without cooking.
Vegans don’t consume dairy or anything from animals based on the same logic and compassion that leads vegetarians to not eat meat. It’s about the suffering of the animals. If you thought animals didn’t suffer to give you dairy or eggs you’d be wrong. Vegans avoid dairy on the premise that the production of dairy causes animals to suffer and even premature death. You see the modern world is about profit. We have taken hold of animals, against their natural habitats and exploited them for our own greed. Imagine human slavery still existed, wouldn’t we as Sikhs be vocal?
Lets look at eggs, did you know male chicks are grinded alive when born as they don’t produce eggs and therefore aren’t profitable. For you non egg eaters thinking you’re off the hook let’s look at dairy. Cows and buffalos just like women only produce milk when lactating. Because there are supermarket shelves to be kept filled, cows are often forcefully impregnated so they can produce milk and and kept into wretched cycle of being impregnated and giving milk until they whither away and die. Just to add insult to injury their baby calves are taken away from their mothers at birth and slaughtered for meat (veal).
I don’t want to get too graphic, but the truth needs to be told. You can be pretty certain that all milk found in supermarkets which is so cheap has been a product of this factory farming system. Of course paneer, yoghurt, ghee, cheese and all the rest of it comes from the same source. If you’re interested to learn more you can watch documentaries like Cowspiracy, Earthlings, Forks Over Knives and Vegucated. I became Vegan after seeing these documentaries.
We all are sold the story about pollution and rightly so we need to be aware. But did you know that raising livestock and their byproducts are responsible for 51% of all worldwide greenhouse gas emissions. Here’s us sitting idol with our Bag for Life and energy saving light bulbs. Clearly turning vegan would have a larger impact.
Animal agriculture alone is responsible for more greenhouse gas emissions that all combined transport of the world. Don’t bother checking miles per gallon.
Vegans tend to have lower cancer risks than meat eaters and vegetarians alike.
Vegan diets are lower in saturated fats, animal hormones, cholesterol and the natural incline towards more fruits and vegetables means less chances of cancers, obesity, heart disease and diabetes (the worlds largest killers).
Vegans get their protein from products like lentils, black beans, veggie burgers, tofu, nuts, peanut butter, and soy milk. These contain no cholesterol and in fact contain cholesterol lowering fibre.
Grains that are used to feed livestock could feed over a billion people.
Animal agriculture is responsible for 20-33% of the worlds fresh water consumption today.
It takes 1/6th of an acre of land to feed a Vegan for a year. Vegetarians need 3X the land, and meat eaters need 18X the land.
It takes 1000 gallons of water to produce 1 gallon of milk.
It takes 2500 gallons of water to produce a pound of beef whereas only 25 gallons to produce a pound of wheat.
One thing is clear from these facts and the documentaries. We are wasting a HUGE deal of resources for something that isn’t needed. There are plenty of vegans out there living happy and healthy lifestyles.
Eating as a Vegan
Now there are a lot of myths to dispel, especially the one of protein. The truth is you don’t need as much protein as they fitness community will have you believe and that you can get all you need from vegan sources.
Vegans have reported increased blood flow, increased energy, better digestion and even increased recovery from workouts. It’s fair to say there are shortcomings too, things like Zinc, Vitamin B12 and Iron should be monitored carefully and in the case of Vitamin B12 and Vitamin D, supplementation is probably advised.
I have been vegetarian since 2012 and vegan since November 2015. My training has only been impacted in a positive way, I’m exploring a whole palette of foods I never even heard of and everyday I’m being asked ‘vegan, what do you eat?’
I’m now responding with ‘what we as humans should be eating’. Natural foods free of suffering and pain.
Should Gurdware be doing more?
It could be argued most of our Sikhi teaching comes from the online platform instead of Gurdware but Gurdware still have a huge role to play in our Sikhi. What type of message does it send out when Gurdware serve langar containing dairy from these terrible conditions. It could just be a case of being unaware, but unfortunately people aren’t attracted to Gurdware for the spiritual reasons so much as they are for chips and beans langar or a specific baba. There’s a lot wrong with Gurdware and the way they’re run, that should be saved for another day. When it comes to truth, spirituality and compassion one can’t help feel let down by the very places that Gurmat and the virtues should be coming to us from. With high cholesterol and high diabetes rates in the Punjabi community it definitely seems like a responsibility Sikhs in the UK and our Gurdware need to tackle head on and become aware of.
Sometimes it needs to be asked, if the Gurus were around today would they approve of factory farming? Exploiting other living beings for our own greed. One thing is clear we certainly don’t need meat and dairy. The American Dietetics Association in 2009 concluded that ‘appropriately planned… vegan diets, are healthful, nutritionally adequate, and may provide health benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases.’
If you’re an Amritdhari Sikh ask yourselves a question. Why don’t you eat meat? Hopefully the answer will be more than because the rehat says so. If compassion and empathy are at the forefront of your reasoning then shouldn’t you be vegan considering all of the exploitative practices that surround vegetarian-suitable foods: eggs and dairy.
6 thoughts on “Should Sikhs Be Vegan?”
Love what you write and always a fan of yours. In my limited understanding, Bhagat Kabeer ji, talks about eating meat, in a particular context. He mentions that it is unwise and illegal to eat meat in the name of holy sacrifice of an animal. Same goes for Hindu brahmins, who would sacrifice goats, or lambs and then where would that dead body go, basically cooked as meat, and eaten as parshad.
So there is no direct saying by our guru to abstain from eating meat. (I don’t eat meat at all.) It is a topic which is irrelevant in our growth of Sikhi, because in my opinion what we eat does not make me a good human. What we eat mentally and spiritually definitely does.
Guru Nanak ji, has mentioned, in the baani ‘mit khaaana, mit bolnaa, mit pehnaa…’ – that we should be utilizing these various resources only to our needs, and not to our pleasure.
So at some point you are right, that eating meat is for pleasure. It should never be eaten in the name of parshad, after sacrificing animals. And I am against consuming meat, when the animals are treated in the most inhumane way for our pleasure and consumption.
On a separate note-
We should not interpret baani, just from two lines. The entire salok, or shabad gives the right context. Especially the rahao part. If I were to interpret the baani from just two lines, then our beloved Bhagat Kabeer ji also says about hairs-
SGGS – Ang 324
ਮੂਡ ਮੁੰਡਾਏ ਜੌ ਸਿਧਿ ਪਾਈ ॥
ਮੁਕਤੀ ਭੇਡ ਨ ਗਈਆ ਕਾਈ ॥੨॥
ਭਾਵੈ ਲਾਂਬੇ ਕੇਸ ਕਰੁ ਭਾਵੈ ਘਰਰਿ ਮੁਡਾਇ ॥੨੫॥ – If I just interpret one line, it would mean, I can either shave my head or keep hairs.
Sorry, If I took away the essence of the topic or the blog in general.
I could write a book on why Sikhs and the rest of the world should embrace veganism, but I will keep it short and primarily focus on the Sikhs. There are many references in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji on the importance of compassion for all living sentient beings and staying away from meat. The 6th Guruji and 10th Guruji hunted animals who were hurting people and their livelihood as well as those souls who were destined to go to Sachkhand without waiting to become human. All of this comes down to belief and faith. Any human can argue any religion. They only ate meat when their opponents stopped their food supplies, but never for the sake of their taste bud because their tongues were not lustful. Nowadays, dairy and honey (OK to consume in Sikhi) are not compassionate anymore because humans have turned animals and their by-products into commodities and greedy global business. If you watch any vegan documentary and animal abuse video, you will realize veganism is about justice and rights for all sentient livings beings. It is not about personal preference and lifestyle choices. It is not about your and my taste buds. Baptized Sikhs have a moral and social responsibility to adopt a vegan lifestyle and promote it along with Vaheguru’s teachings. I can go on and on, but I advise you folks to watch Gary Yourofsky’s 2010 Best Speech on YouTube.
I totally agree with you I have just come back from a sikhi camp I was disappointed when one of well respected gurusikh answered a question of a person asking if kara prashad can be vegan as they have allergies. His reply was veganism is a healthy diet and that the four core ingredients used to make it can not be changed. I tried to voice the animal cruelty but the lady I spoke to said she didn’t understand veganism…
Thanks for this read. I’m actually not Sikh but have been reading about Sikhism and I think that you have a very beautiful faith. I’m vegan also and through various searches this is where google took me. Very well put on all accounts. Thanks for sharing.
A Very well written article. I have been studying Sikhism and this was incredibly helpful. Thanks a lot.
Thank you for an excellent article!
May all beings be free from suffering. 🙏🏽